The best places in Tampa to get a Thanksgiving pie

A piece of pie next to a full pie
Photo courtesy The Pearl

Thanksgiving is about many things—loved ones, turkey, football. But our favorite part of Thanksgiving is the excuse to eat as much pie as we can dream of. Luckily, there are plenty of places in town helping to make those dreams come true.

Whether it’s for friendsgiving, the whole family, or just you and whatever looks good on Netflix, there’s no bad excuse for eating a fresh-baked pie. Here are some of the top spots in Tampa to find a great pie this Thanksgiving and holiday season.

ADVERTISEMENT

Some of these you’ll need to order well in advance. A handful you can pick up any time you like. Be sure to check with individual businesses for details on ordering and pickup.

Know a great spot we missed? Shoot us an email at info@thatssotampa.com so we can add it!

A pie on a counter
Photo courtesy Alessi Bakery

Top spots for pie in Tampa

Alessi Bakery
2909 W Cypress St
Alessi has been baking up the best in Tampa for more than 100 years. This is the pie menu dreams are made of.

Boulon Brasserie & Bakery
1001 Water Street
The French star on Water Street Tampa has three specialty homemade pies this year: Bourbon-Spiced Apple Tart, Hummingbird Pecan Tart with a Whisky Caramel; and Pumpkin Velours Pie

Chocolate Pi
5207 N Florida Ave
One of the best spots in Tampa for fresh-baked goodies is featuring plenty of great pies, including: Old-fashioned apple pi; Southern Pecan pi; and Chocolate pecan pi.

Fat Beet Farm Kitchen & Bakery
13830 W Hillsborough Ave
This farm-to-table kitchen and bakery is whipping up everything you need for the holidays, including fresh pies and other sweet treats. Choose from Apple Crumble or a tropical Bahama Blue Pie, or mix things up with the seasonal Pumpkin Swiss Roll.

A pie on a counter
Photo courtesy Boulon Brasserie & Bakery

HaleLife Bakery
1155 South Dale Mabry Hwy
These are amazing baked goods that also happen to be gluten-free, vegan, and allergen-friendly. Pumpkin Pie, Apple Crumble Pie, and Peach Cobbler feature on this year’s menu. Online pre-order only.

Moreno Bakery
737 W Brandon Blvd, Brandon
This local staple has just about every pie you could imagine, from traditional holiday favorites to specialty cream and fruit pies. Give them a call to place your order, and be sure to get it in by November 23.

Pané Rustica
3225 S MacDill Ave
This restaurant and artisan bakery is baking the classics, including Pecan, Pumpkin, and even Cranberry Blueberry pie. Beyond the pies, don’t miss the Pumpkin Cheesecake or selection of specialty breads. Be sure to place your order by November 21.

Psomi
701 N Howard Ave
The beloved Greek restaurant and bakery has some delicious pie options this year. Choose from Pumpkin Pie, Pecan Pie, an Apple Bougatsa Pie with baklava streusel, or a Cranberry Cheesecake Pie. Regular and mini-sized pies available.

La Segunda
2512 N 15th St, 4015 W Kennedy Blvd
This historic Cuban bakery is bringing all the holiday classics to the table this year. Choose from a selection of traditional pies, including apple, pecan, sweet potato, and pumpkin. Call or stop by the bakery to place your preorder.

State Flower Bakery
5224 S Dale Mabry Hwy
This highly-rated local gem in South Tampa has an incredible lineup of scratch-made pies year-round. Pre-orders must be made by November 19.

Sucré Table
4048 W Kennedy Blvd
The Tampa star has three traditional pies— Salted Caramel Apple, Pumpkin, and Bourbon Pecan – as well as a Champagne Poached Pear Cheesecake and a Hazelnut Tiramisu Tart. Pick-up orders must be placed at least two days ahead of pick-up dates. Preorder ends November 19.

Wright’s Gourmet House
1200 S Dale Mabry Hwy
The bakery at Wright’s has rolled out a pair of seasonal favorites, with Pumpkin Pie and Pumpkin Raisin Nut Gingerbread Loaf. If it’s an early meal, quiches count as pies, too!

Don't miss a story 👉

Get all the best local content delivered to your inbox

👇 Don't Miss a Story 👇

Recent Stories