Madison Avenue Pizza serves the biggest—and craziest—pizza in the Bay

If you’re a professional eater, or an active user of social media, you’ve probably already heard of Madison Avenue Pizza. With pies up to 32 inches, in flavors such as “Chik-fil-A” or the pickle-topped “Cuban,” this Dunedin hot spot is known for serving the biggest—and boldest—pizza in the Bay.

Today, we visited the Instagram-famous pizzeria for an inside look at some of its wildest offerings.

Advertisement

Pushing the “pizza limits”

“I like to push the limits on what is and isn’t pizza,” owner Sean Ferraro said as we perused his menu. “And what can be done with pizza.”

No stranger to the restaurant industry, Sean has worked in food service since the age of 12. From dish washing at his parents’ restaurants to later searing and sautéing in five diamond hotels, the entrepreneur is truly a “jack-of-all-trades” in the culinary realm. After a lifetime of serving others, however, he decided to start his own place.

“I knew I wanted to have a restaurant since I was a kid,” he said, “But five years ago, I just really got the itch to do my own thing. I love to create, so I wanted the opportunity to create things for myself.”

In 2017, he opened Madison Avenue Pizza.

The Bay’s most outrageous slices

From day one, Sean’s inventive, artistic spirit has guided the way he runs his restaurant. His passion for creativity is visible in many of his top-selling—and internet renowned—pizzas.

Advertisement

“Hands-down our two most popular pizzas are the ‘Chick-fil-A’ and the ‘Crab Rangoon,’” he said. “One’s got a Chik-fil-A Sauce base with waffle fries and nuggets, and the other has crab Rangoon filling, scallions and crispy wontons.”

Both of these pizzas, however, are weekly, rotating “specials.” Though the permanent menu offers some crazy pies, the most outrageous items are only available for fleeting moments. This model helps Sean satisfy his need for spontaneity and invention. To keep up with what Madison Avenue is serving each day, therefore, foodies should visit the spot’s Instagram or Facebook.

So, long story short: we can’t guarantee exactly what Sean will be cooking when you stop in. Through past examples—and our personal experience—however, we can give you a pretty good idea of what’s possible.

From the best-of-the-best of the permanent menu items, to the most memorable of the “weekly specials,” therefore, here are some of the wildest pies Madison Ave has put on the plate.

The pizzas

Flamin’ Hot Cheeto Mac Daddy

TOPPINGS: Mac and cheese, hot Cheeto breaded chicken tenders, ranch, buffalo sauce, green onions and “a dusting of more hot Cheetos”

Chick-fil-A

TOPPINGS: Chick-fil-A sauce base, mozzarella, cheddar, nuggets, waffle fries, pickles, chives and more Chick-fil-A sauce on top

Chicken and Waffles

TOPPINGS: Mozzarella and cheddar base (no pizza sauce), homemade chicken nuggets, homemade waffles, bacon and chives. Served with a side of maple syrup.

Advertisement

Cuban

TOPPINGS: House-made slow-roasted mojo pork, mozzarella, swiss, ham, salami, pickles and mayo-mustard sauce

Crab Rangoon

TOPPINGS: House-made crab rangoon filling, mozzarella, sushi-grade crab sticks, wonton strips, green onions and a sweet and sour sauce drizzle

Shrimp Scampi

TOPPINGS: Olive oil base, spinach, mozzarella, Jensen Brother’s shrimp (seasoned and sautéed), “a generous amount of fresh garlic,” white wine reduction and grated Parmigiano Reggiano cheese

Pickle

TOPPINGS: Dill garlic sauce, mozzarella, thin-sliced dill pickles and fresh dill

Return of the Mac

TOPPINGS: A sesame seed crust with a “secret sauce” base, mozzarella, yellow American cheese, ground beef, iceberg lettuce, onion, pickle and more secret sauce

Toasted Ravioli

TOPPINGS: Traditional pizza sauce base, mozzarella, St. Louis-imported Provel cheese, Louisiana toasted beef ravioli, fresh basil and grated parmesan

32-inch “Biggest Pizza in the Bay”

TOPPINGS: Foodie’s choice

Advertisement

(Finish it with a partner—or by yourself—in one hour and Madison Avenue will donate $100 to Dunedin Cares Food Pantry)

Want a “pizza” the action?

Whether you’re looking for a pizza that’ll blow up on TikTok, or one big enough to put professional eaters to shame, Madison Avenue Pizza has got you covered. But, if you’re into surprises, we highly recommend just going for the weekly special.

From potato chips to marshmallows, you never know what Sean and his team will be piling on their dough.

Madison Avenue Pizza is located at 2660 Bayshore Blvd in Dunedin. To view the restaurant’s permanent menu, foodies can visit its official website. To keep up with weekly specials, foodies can follow the spot on Instagram or Facebook.

What to read next: 

Don't miss a story 👉

Get all the best local content delivered to your inbox

👇 Don't Miss a Story 👇

Recent Stories